Worst movie based on a Comic

Definitly without a doubt Dare-Devil Ben affleck butcherd it and the Dare-Devil character in itself is very flawed

Hands down Superman III and IV. III killed the franchise and IV buried it.

I'm one of the few that totally loved Daredevil and Elektra - heck, I think that DD is one of the best of the genre.

But for the person that didn't like Spider-Man...Whiskey Tango Foxtrot?

True true

I liked DD, Elektra was eh OK

Any movie like superman that is extended to the 3 and 4 is bound to flop.

Hulk was decent

Spawn sucked

as did Judge Dredd (im still holding out for a decent 2000AD film)

but ya gotta love "i don't break the law, I AM THE LAW"

catwoman was like a car wreck

and Dare Devil was lame since when is the kingpin black?

Hulk was ok but overly long and not enough hulk screen time to much waffle and angst

Spidey Rules
as does Xmen

Spawn sucked

as did Judge Dredd (im still holding out for a decent 2000AD film)

but ya gotta love "i don't break the law, I AM THE LAW"

catwoman was like a car wreck

and Dare Devil was lame since when is the kingpin black?

Hulk was ok but overly long and not enough hulk screen time to much waffle and angst

Spidey Rules
as does Xmen

My favourite part of the punisher is when john travolta shoots the guy on the floor at the beginning, a guy who's supposed to be dead already, and he flinches when he's shot. GOLD! despite those kind of production values, i would have to go with daredevil. It's not a good sign when you want to see the hero get his ass kicked.

Catwoman=Halle Berry Hot, the movie.... Not so much.

Spiderman= Killer!

Superman, any of them=Sucks, why? THE GUY IS IMMORTAL! HE CAN'T DIE! I like a super hero who can die, like Spiderman, in the comic world he died, his daughter took over. But Super Man? Shot, in the heart, with a Kryptonite bullet, gets up, kicks butt, then goes "Oops that's right this is supposed to be my weakness, oh well."

But worse?

Garfield! They just, don't have, it. You know? They don't have Garfield, his character, his attitude, surprised no one mentioned him yet.

I loved it, but just because it was so rediculous.

www.culttvman.com...

And , unlike the first movie, had nothing to do with the comic whatsoever.

I am waiting for hollywood to make my all time favorite superhero into a movie ...."The Rocket Racer!" Please make this movie and I will buy multiple copies of it and send them to my family and friends. Rocket Racer was somewhat of a lower tier hero who made an appearance in a Spider-Man book about 25 to 30 years ago aproximately. He was so cool with his rocket equipped skateboard and disco attire. "Eat my dust!" Rocket Racer rules!

Hulk (2003).

Just.. not enough smashing, not enough angry hulk, the hulk is much too passive in the movie, and overall the movie just stank. I wasted my money going to see it, and even worse i wasted my time opening it on christmas morning.

DD- liked it
Electra- take it or leave it
Catwomen- hated it
Punisher- like it
Hulk- Like it
Spawn- like it
V for vedetta- loved it
Batman- loved all but Batman & Robin
Spiderman- loved both
Old F4 movie- horrible
New F4 movie- awesome
Thor, Iron man- can't wait
Ghost rider- can wait
Wonder women- wait until dvd

Spawn it was so cheesy

I want a remake of Spawn and I want it done RIGHT!

Yeah well keep waiting cause it's never going to happen LOL

Never?

Second Spawn movie...

i have to agree, judge dredds personality was too watered down compared to his comics.
Stallone just didnt have the character either IMO. it was his rambo character but with an overly flashy suit.

same as spiderman and a few others including the recent ghost rider, some are just too scripted or maybe they use try hard actors.

what the hell is with that oversize crotch piece?

image source: http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/hollywood_pictures/judge_dredd/sylvester_stallone/dredd.jpg


image source: http://www.infinite-insomnia.com/L_Image/Justice.jpg






[edit on 28/12/07 by Obliv_au]

[edit on 28/12/07 by Obliv_au]

I have to say Superman III is by far the worst...

The worst comic movie ever made by far has to be Catwoman. The only thing that had in common with the comics was name only!

Batman Forever and Batman and Robin are two more that need to be put on this list. When I saw Batman Forever in theaters, I almost walked out when the Batmobile started driving UP a wall.

For what Captain America was, I thought it was ok. Sure, it was waaaaaaaaay campy, but it's kinda good.

The first Punisher movie I thought was decent, but it was still low budget Marvel fashion. The same goes for the original FF movie too, but with alot more camp and no money. The Thing and Doctor Doom's costumes looked great though!

I never knew they made a Captain America movie

It's next to impossible to find any copys. I had to go through Amazon.com for mine.


If you don't like camp, then I'd suggest not watching it. I thought it was ok, but it is pretty bad when it comes down to it.

All of them. They usually never go by the story anyways.